NEW GENERATION OFFENSIVE RUBBER
Don Iguana
ABSTRACT
Don Iguana Labs tested four sheets of recently introduced offensive rubber in
maximum sponge thickness. Tests were conducted with all four sheets primed and
lightly speed glued with Spintech Enduro 50/50 Booster Blend. Sheets were
mounted on two identical Spintech 9th Wonder blades, chosen as a fast, stiff
platform that would minimize rubber/blade interactions and highlight
differences. Unglued impressions were obtained with sheets staying mounted after
previous test, one week earlier. Test included cooperative offensive drilling
and practice matches in which the tester alternated sides and blades over a four
game match. The tester experienced each sheet on each "wing" for one game.
OVERVIEW
Butterfly Tempest, Butterfly Cermet, Banda Sigma and
Tibhar Makss are all "new generation" offensive rubbers that offer some
combination of softer, finer grade (small cell) sponge and thin top sheets.
Tempest is now claimed to be the fastest rubber in the daunting Butterfly line
and Cermet is their latest foray into tensioned no glue/light glue products.
Tibhar Makss touts the thinnest top sheet around and 2.6 soft sponge in Max
thickness. Banda Sigma is not heavily promoted, but is the Innova Ultra Light
sponged brother to hot selling Stiga Magna (which appears to the use the same
top sheet with "regular" Innova sponge.)
TEST IMPRESSIONS SUMMARY
BUTTERFLY TEMPEST - New territory, even to the naked eye. Our red Tempest
test sheet was blood red (darker and less transparent than Bryce) and the pink
sponge lacked the familiar BTY "LED" style numbering system. Our educated test
crew surmises that this may not be from the same assembly line as many of
Butterfly's horses. Tempest is, however, a worthy contender for Bryce's crown as
the Baddest Butterfly. Most similar to the Nittaku Hammond Pro Alpha recently
tested here, Tempest is a more compliant weapon than Bryce and has great touch
around the table. It has the most linear response of the sheets in the test.
Yes, every gear, despite a clear development goal to create some built-in
tension in the sandwich. Is it an 11 and off the factory speed chart? Damn
close.
BUTTERFLY CERMET - Wonderful cork and driving power! It is quite similar
to Tempest in feel but with longer dwell time and a higher throw. The best fast
spinning rubber in the test and the best for opening top spin against the push.
Perhaps the best news about Cermet is not these expected characteristics for
"tensioned" rubber but rather its unexpected speed and resistance to stall.
Catapult is a good tensioned product, but has just a slight mushy feel on balls
struck "too directly". Cermet exhibits none of those tendencies, playing more
like soft Bryce than fast Catapult. Opening loops with Cermet were low, wickedly
juiced and quite controllable.
BANDA SIGMA - This sheets is a very good value for the all round player
and anyone who wants premium quality without "intro" prices. It has the least
grip of this group but is quite predictable and very nicely sponged for counter
spinning. The Innova Ultra Light sponge shows more life under this Magna top
sheet than in the original Innova UL form. As such, Sigma offers longer dwell
time than Magna but retains the improved speed found in Stiga's hot new seller.
For many of the more artistic among us, Banda Sigma is a sleeper that seems to
reward creativity at every turn.
TIBHAR MAKSS - This ultra thin top sheet German product has a polarizing
effect. You either love it or hate it. It has extremely high throw angles and a
big cork...but is actually more of a speed rubber than a spin rubber. What 2.6
speed glued sponge will do is catch an incoming loop and let you rip back. The
faster the impact the more dynamic Makss becomes, sometimes spraying the ball
too wide, but other times crushing balls into unhittable places when your hands
are moving in the right direction :) Makss is a 40 mm medium range weapon that
can add punch to any control top spinner's strokes.
TABLE GAME RATINGS
- Tempest Max
- Banda Sigma Max
- Cermet Max
- Makss 2.6
Surprisingly, the fast
Tempest is more predictable and speed responsive for service, service return and
pushing than others in the test. Its low throw angle and high speed make it a
dream for flipping and works well when it comes time to pull out the occasional
driving serve. Clearly, sweeter at slow speed than Bryce or MP. Sigma's modest
grip and medium soft sponge also encourage confident short play. Cermet and
Makss were quite lively and very spinny but these two sheets respond to
everything...which is not always a good thing :)
THROW ANGLE (HIGH TO LOW)
- Makss 2.6
- Cermet Max
- Banda Sigma Max
- Tempest Max
Makss' masquerade as a spin
rubber begins with its high throw angle. Over time you come to appreciate that
the Makss ball doesn't really grip and force long blocks at the other
end...instead the high throw allows you to bash forward with enough spin to make
the ball hit and enough speed to force errors. It is a speed rubber that
launches like spin rubber. Like Goldilocks, this tester loved the "Just Right"
angle from Cermet. Perfect for lifting your openers against backspin with tons
of top when it lands.
HITTING, COUNTERING AND
BLOCKING
- Tempest Max
- Cermet Max
- Banda Sigma Max
- Makss 2.6
The Butterfly brothers both
come to life as the pace picks up. Like Sriver on steroids (or perhaps Bryce on
its best behavior) Tempest and Cermet are visually faster and sound crisper in
at-the-table exchanges.
LOOPING AND OPENING
- Cermet Max
- Makss 2.6
- Tempest Max
- Banda Sigma Max
All four of the sheets excel
in this department, as they should by design. Makss does not make much spin, but
it is so sweet in the apogee department, it must be placed highly. The clear
edge here goes to Cermet. As we groped around for a "comparable feel" maybe
heavily glued Sriver EL comes to mind to describe Cermet. There were many
"accidental winners" hit in this drill with Tempest, rocketing winners launched
Dr. Strangelove style...dumbly deadly. Really, most would not be displeased with
any of these sheets for three ball offense.
COUNTER SPINNING
- Makss 2.6
- Cermet Max
- Tempest Max
- Banda Sigma Max
Again, there was consistent
competency in the group, especially for 40 mm style spin-hitting. Makss seemed
to impart the most "will" when redirecting high speed incoming spin. Cermet
probably had the most spin landing on the other side. Tempest has soo much speed
at this pace, hitting seems the more natural mode.
CONTROL AND VERSATILITY
- Banda Sigma Max
- Tempest Max
- Cermet Max
- Makss 2.6
Banda wins here. Do not
mistake this category for the "booby prize". All round play still has a place at
all but the very top level of 40 mm tournament table tennis and Sigma plays much
like the 38 mm standards of yore...adding some speed and elasticity to bring the
40 mm back into the "old box" of stroke selection. Only the Tibhar would really
qualify as a "good hands only" choice, since both Butterfly sheets had
relatively good manners considering they had a little more speed and spin.
UNGLUED
- Cermet Max
- Tempest Max
- Banda Sigma Max
- Makss 2.6
LEFTY'S PICK
Hmmm, Don had a hunch and encouraged me to use Tibhar Makss at the Teams and it
served me well, helping me find some dependable offensive in two 50 rating point
wins. But now, with these four sheets mounted together, the Makss seems a little
one dimensional, especially compared to the good gears in these other three. OK,
so give two sheets of lightly glued Butterfly Cermet, please...on the merit of
strong openers and stall resistance.
Courtesy of Dave "Lefty" Williams & About.com
|