BUTTERFLY TACKIFIRE SP - CATAPULT TEST
Don Iguana
TACKIFIRE SP
For Butterfly, adding SP to the Tackifire
family completes their line of high grip products. Players who already prefer
hard sponge 729 and 999 Chinese products now have a comparable sheet made
completely with Japanese quality and technology.
Tackifire SP is as advertised...equally sticky
but faster and harder than other Tackifire and Tackiness offerings. It is the
heaviest sheet of rubber (60 grams per side cut to a compact head size!) and the
stiffest sponge yet encountered by Iguana Labs. Reminding Don of a cold IHOP
pancake, this is one serious slab of rubber.
For anyone nurtured on Japanese rubber (as
discussed in the newsgroup) the first few strokes with Chinese hard sponge are
like walking on Jupiter. Only after a little table time do you even begin to
adjust to the fact that there¹s very little throw at low impacts and that the
best offensive shots generally use equal portions of spin and speed.
In its first session SP showed little glue
effect, with the dense sponge clearly overmatching even the most eager little
catechuic molecules trying to burrow inside. We'll keep gluing and report
back. We've been told persistence is the key to making this sponge jump.
SP plays much like Avalox (999) Purot and very
differently from regular Tackifire, whose feel extends comfortably from other
Butterfly Japanese style offensive rubbers. With SP in the house, Butterfly can
now well serve players in the heavy hitting world of hard sponge grippy rubber.
The input that the company took from King Kong himself (rumored to be sometimes
less than delicately delivered :-) is a good guarantee that this sheet offers
the exact envelope expected.
It's not likely that new players will be
recruited to this style rubber just because Tackifire SP has been introduced,
but Butterfly can compete effectively for a share of the audience already there
for this style with the advantages of a trusted reputation for quality and a
good choice of endorsers.
Rest assured, if you like the "triple number"
rubbers, you'll love this stuff. If you've never visited this part of table
tennis country before, you might wanna bum a test drive before your buy your
ticket.
CATAPULT
If Tackifire SP represents only a logical line
extension in a stable portion of the serious player market, Catapult, by
contrast, raises the bar in an expanding category.
As covered in the July '99 Don Iguana Glue
Sound Test, the Desto F1/Tensor family of glue sound rubbers captures some of
the elements of the glued experience, but not all...generating great spin but
giving up in the speed category when the soft sponge gets down to wood. Shots
get a little unpredictable when really mashed, as if the ball doesn't quite know
whether to rotate and just fly like hell. Glue sounds also tend to lose their
flavor on the bed post overnight, aging quickly under the mechanical stress.
Well school's out boys and girls! Catapult
plays exactly like a comfortably glued sheet of regular rubber and doesn¹t
indicate it will suffer from the shortcomings seen in the first glue sound
generation. We couldn't help but see a family resemblance when we laid a red
sheet of Catapult next to a sheet of Bryce. Speed may be hereditary. At first
glance, it appears the offspring may have spawned with ever so slightly smaller
pips underneath very close together, but it certainly got Daddy's speed.
Time spent with other glue sound rubbers leaves
a feeling of fragility, using thinner top sheets and porous sponge mechanically
stressed to replicate the glue effect. As a result, they deliver more sound
than substance in many cases. Catapult, however, is noticeably more substantial
and matches the performance of a light to medium glue job more accurately. While
Desto F1 seems to mimic the true effect only at low impacts, Catapult allows you
crank up and generate more speed without overmatching the sponge.
Will the US National Team forsake gluing for
the convenience of Catapult? Nahhhh. Does it totally replicate a killer corked
glue job at full tilt? Nahhhh. Is it the best glue sound rubber now on the
market? You bet. Only time will tell if players will "trade down" to it from
gluing, but, right out of the box, Catapult is going to be a great move-up for
non-gluing players that will immediately stretch the spin-speed continuum.
Tested so far only on the
not-legal-in-40-states Ranato assault weapon, Catapult appears to be a hardy,
stable (and faster) solution to this tricky challenge than any of the contenders
that preceded it. We'll report back once we've driven it on the tamer Kong, to
see how much dwell time Catapult can claim on a softer, slower blade.
Courtesy of Dave "Lefty" Williams & About.com
|